It’s an age-old question… “should I reupholster or replace this old, worn out piece of furniture?” Like everything in design, there are no easy answers, but in this post, I offer a few guidelines in helping determine which route might be the better design solution…
1. Sentimentality of the piece
Some furniture pieces own a little piece of our hearts, and as such, I would automatically vote for reupholstery. Old, dated styles can easily be updated and modified by a good upholsterer. Have you just inherited Grandma’s 9′ sofa? We may have a better solution for the piece than simply landfill!
2. Quality of the piece being considered
The reality is that reupholstery labor is expensive and that if the piece isn’t well made, it can be more cost-effective to replace than reupholster. Here are a few ways to quickly assess the quality of a piece when considering what to do with it:
» If the piece is easy to flip over, take a look at its underside. How are the corners reinforced? Is it done only with hardware (i.e. steel brackets & screws?); if yes, that’s not a great sign. Well made pieces should have wood blocks to brace the corner, and the joints should be glued, screwed and double doweled.

Image from Kim's Upholstery
» Feel underneath the piece… is it a hollow space underneath the webbing? Or do you feel steel that goes from front to back of the piece? Eight way hand tied coil spring construction is generally standard in better manufactured pieces and the springs are attached to straps that go from the front of the frame to the back.
» Overall weight… it’s truly a cheater’s way of trying to figure out what’s on the inside of the piece. If it’s heavy, it’s probably got a lot of lumber (kiln-dried hardwood being the best and heavier than soft wood construction), springs, etc. A well made sofa, for example, will weigh close to, or in excess of, 200 pounds. A piece that is relatively easy to lift probably isn’t going to be worth the cost of transporting it to the upholsterers.
» Feel & comfort… while the overall dimensions of a piece will remain the same, furniture will “feel” different once the seat and back cushions are replaced. Different fabrics will also offer a different “feel.” While I consider this when advising a client, I rarely use it as a determining factor.
3. Project Deadlines
If I’m working with a tight deadline, reupholstery is the way to go! I can often turn a reupholstery project around in 2-3 weeks, whereas ordering new, custom furniture generally takes 7-14 weeks.
4. Plenty of Options
There’s little we can’t do with reupholstery and/or new upholstery. With careful thought, both should produce beautiful outcomes!
5. Spend Wisely
Reupholstery will be less expensive than new, well-made, custom furniture, however, it isn’t cheap, so be smart about your decision making and have fun!





















































